Baseball's Greatest Rivalry
There are many rivalries in sports. When people think of baseball I am sure the majority of fans think about the Yankees and Red Sox and their rivalry. That rivalry certainly gets the most attention in the press, and those two teams are the two most popular teams, so of course their rivalry is going to be romanticized. However, it truly does not capture the intensity, the history, and the pedigree that the Dodgers-Giants rivalry has.
The Giants and Dodgers are two of baseball's oldest teams. Their hatred for each other began while the two teams broke ground as two of the premiere teams in New York and Brooklyn, respectively. The Giants represented the wealth and class of big city New York, while the Dodgers represented the knock-hard working class Brooklyn. The cultural rivalry that was represented each time the two teams met on the diamond endured across an entire continent, when the Dodgers moved to Los Angeles and the Giants moved to San Francisco: two cities which have always fought and struggled with another to be the beacon of the American West.
Unlike the Yankees-Red Sox rivalry, which has been historically one-sided, the Dodgers-Giants rivalry is uncannily even insofar as the success of the two franchises is concerned. The Giants have beaten the Dodgers 1164 times, while the Dodgers have won 1147 times. Additionally, the Dodgers have 22 pennants while the Giants have 20; the Dodgers have 6 World Series titles, while the Giants have 5. Indeed, the rivalry between these two teams has always been fresh and intense, due to the fact the two teams always have something to prove to another.
The rivalry, being the longest in sports' history, has may great moments. The Shot Heard Round the World, is perhaps the greatest moment in the history of call sports. Juan Marichal's viscous attack on Johnny Rosboro with a bat remains the most viscous episode of violence in the history of professional baseball. Brian Johnson's 12th-inning homerun agains the Dodgers in 1997, which sent the Giants into the post-season, remains one of the greatest homeruns in Giants' history.
A New Chapter
And now, the Giants and Dodgers have yet another game to add to the long list of epic moments the often results when these two franchises meet. On July 20, 2010 the Giants and Dodgers met at Chavez Ravine to play game 2 of their three-game series. The Giants had not fared well against the Dodgers at all this year. Going into the series the Dodgers had beaten the Giants 5 times, including a sweep at AT&T Park, while the Giants had beaten the Dodgers once. The Giants were able to beat their rivals on July 19, 2010, and going into game 2 it seemed like the Giants would be able to win their first series against their rivals, as Tim Lincecum was taking the mound against Clayton Kershaw.
Also on the minds of many Giants fans was when the Giants were going to get revenge. Earlier in the season, Dodger starting-pitcher Vicente Padilla threw a ball that hit Aaron Rowand in the face, fracturing the Giants' center fielder's cheek bone; an injury that would sideline him for several weeks. Many of us anticipated the Giants would retaliate when the Dodgers came to San Francisco, but nothing happened and it seemed that Rowand's injury would be forgotten.
The game began immediately with the Dodgers drilling Giants' lead-off man, Andres Torres. Again, Giants fans wondered when the retaliation would come. It appeared that the Dodgers were going to continue to bully our players and no one on our staff would get revenge. As a blood thirsty fan you want to see blood whenever a Dodger pitcher hits a Giants batter. However, to make matters worse, Lincecum did not have his stuff going for him. He threw some pitches randomly into the air, he could barely hit the strike-zone, and before he was taken out in the fifth inning he had given up five runs.
In the fifth-inning however, with the Giants down 5 to 1, the tensions would escalate. With Matt Kemp at the plate, on the 1-0 pitch, Lincecum threw a ball high and inside, which brushed Kemp back, knocking him to the ground. Boos echoed throughout Dodger Stadium as Kemp stood up and resumed his stance in the box. With the next pitch, Lincecum threw at Kemp again, hitting the Dodger-slugger in the back. Kemp marched out in front of the plate and watching the game you wondered if he would charge the mound. Lincecum, for his part, stepped off the mound and turned his back to Kemp as the Dodger fumed and marched to first base. Pablo Sandoval rushed forward and stood between Kemp and Lincecum. The tension subsided and the game went on.
The drama would return however. Pablo Sandoval hit a three-run double in the 6th inning that brought the game to 5-4. With Aaron Rowand at the plate in the 7th, Dodger pitcher Clayton Kershaw threw a ball right at Rowand, hitting him in the leg. Due to the fact that Kershaw had been warned about retaliation, he was ejected along with manager Joe Torre. The game went out without any more immediate drama.
In the bottom of the ninth, the Giants managed to get a man on second and third. Jonathan Broxton, the elite closer for the Dodgers, came on to close out the game and to protect the slim 5-4 lead Los Angeles had. After Broxton came on he walked the first batter he saw to load the bases. After that perhaps one of the weirdest rules lawyering happened that I have ever seen in baseball would end up helping the Giants mount one of the most epic comebacks in recent history.
Mattingly, the Dodgers coach after Torre and their second in command had been ejected, came out to talk with the Dodgers and Broxton. The men huddled on the field and discussed strategy for a moment. After a short time they broke. Mattingly stepped off the mound and onto the grass. As he did so, James Loney, first baseman for the Dodgers, asked a question. Mattingly spun around and stepped back onto the mound in order to answer.
|Renteria scores the winning run.|
Rule 8.06 of Baseball limits the amount of mound visits a coach can make during the same batter. Subsection (b) holds that "a second trip to the same pitcher in the same inning will cause [the] pitcher's removal." Lastly, subsection (d) holds that "a manager or coach is considered to have concluded his visit to the mound when he leaves the 18-foot circles surrounding the pitcher's rubber."
After a short argument, Jonathan Broxton, the elite-closer for the Dodgers was taken out of the game. In to replace him was George Sherrill, one of the biggest disappointments in major league baseball this year. After just two pitches, Andres Torres hit a shot into left-center, which scored two runs and gave the Giants the lead, and after a shut down from Brian Wilson, the Giants were able to steal away a game from the Dodgers and stun them. It was one of those moments that harken back to the glory days of baseball. It was one of those moments that fired up an entire fanbase and let us all know that the 2010 Giants have a fire in their hearts and are going to try their hardest to go deep this year.
A Rivalry Renewed?
During the Bonds years there was a fervor in the Giants-Dodgers rivalry. Dodgers fans hated Barry Bonds. He was the best player in the game and he played for their hated enemy. Giants fans loved to see Barry beat LA. Since Bonds left, however, the rivalry, at least from the perspective in San Francisco, lost a little of its pop. The Giants were hardly competitive through 2007 and 2008, thus the rivalry lost a little of its fun. Moreover, for all the hatred that existed between the fans of these two franchises, you always had to wonder where the hatred was between the players, if it existed at all.
With modernity, a lot of these rivalries fizzled out on the field. In the early days of baseball many of the players on major league teams were actually from the cities they played in. They often grew up rooting for the teams they played for. And many of them lived within blocks of the stadiums where they worked each day. Thus, players of yesteryear understood how the fans felt. They understood what it was like to hate the Dodgers or hate the Giants. Because they grew up being in the same place as the fans had been.
Now, however, with baseball being an extremely professional and sophisticated business, most players do not play for the team they grew up rooting for. In fact, several Giants players today, such as Sergio Romo and Barry Zito, actually grew up rooting for the Dodgers. Thus, much of the hatred for the Dodgers, which is so personal for fans, is simply not there for the players.
|Suck it Russel Martin.|
In 2009, the Giants and Dodgers cleared the benches at AT&T park after Pablo Sandoval and Russel Martin got into an argument at the plate. No punches were thrown but it looked like something serious was brewing. This year, Aaron Rowand has been thrown at twice. Matt Kemp has been hit. Andres Torres has been hit. Russel Martin got a brush-back. And after 20 July, the Dodgers suffered one of their most humiliating losses in years.
There is no telling if further retaliation will come. However, coming this week the Dodgers will return to AT&T Park. Let's hope another chapter in the rivalry will be written.